This is an important heads-up regarding the GATK 3.0 release.

The purpose of the ReduceReads algorithm was to enable joint analysis of large cohorts by the UnifiedGenotyper. The new workflow for joint discovery, which involves doing a single-sample pass with the HaplotypeCaller in gVCF mode followed by a joint analysis on multiple sample gVCFs, renders the compression step obsolete.

In addition, based on our most recent analyses, we have come to the conclusion that the quality of variant calls made on BAMs compressed with ReduceReads is inferior to the standard targeted by GATK tools. In comparison, the results obtained with the new workflow are far superior.

For these reasons, we have made the difficult decision to remove the ReduceReads tool from version 3.0 of the toolkit. To be clear, reduced BAMs will NOT be supported in GATK 3.0.

We realize that this may cause some disruption to your existing workflows, and for that we apologize. Please understand that we are driven to provide tools that produce the best possible results. Now that all the data is in, we have found that the best results cannot be achieved with reduced BAMs, so we feel that the best thing to do is to remove this inferior tool from the toolkit, and promote the new tools.

As always we welcome your comments, and we look forward to showing you how the new calling workflow will yield superior results.


jpitt


Hi @Geraldine_VdAuwera, Thanks for the heads up on this! Since I saw this post I've looked around without much success. Is HaplotypeCaller's gVCF and subsequent multi-sample gVCF calling implemented in the current 2.8.1 build of GATK, or do we need to wait until 3.0 is released? Also, for multi-sample calling you say that ReducedReads + UnifiedGenotyper perform subotimally compared to HaplotypeCaller + gVCF. Does this mean that the calls obtained from ReducedReads bams are inherently poor? More specifically, are ReducedReads + UnifiedGenotyper calls of much lower quality than regular bams + UnifiedGenotyper calls? Assuming that HaplotypeCaller gVCF is coming in version 3.0, would your team advise against using ReducedReads bams in the meantime? Thanks!

Tue 4 Mar 2014

Geraldine_VdAuwera


Hi @jpitt, The gVCF (or reference model) is already implemented in 2.8, though it is further improved in the 3.0 code. However the tools for making joint analyses based on gVCFs of multiple samples (which is what replaces RR+UG) are not yet available; they will be in the new release. Which, if all goes well, will be released tomorrow! So I would advise waiting a day or two for the new version to be available. > are ReducedReads + UnifiedGenotyper calls of much lower quality than regular bams + UnifiedGenotyper calls? It's all relative, but let's say that they are inferior enough (particularly to the results we get with the new method) that we absolutely encourage you to switch over to the new method.

Tue 4 Mar 2014

BretH


How will you be filtering out low-information reads (like pcr duplicates)? Or are these included in the joint varient analysis step?

Tue 4 Mar 2014

Geraldine_VdAuwera


Hi @BretH, We mark duplicates using Picard tools in pre-processing, same as previously. This causes GATK tools to ignore dupes in subsequent analyses.

Tue 4 Mar 2014

BretH


Thank you for your answer.

Tue 4 Mar 2014




- Recent posts


- Upcoming events

See Events calendar for full list and dates


- Recent events

See Events calendar for full list and dates



- Follow us on Twitter

GATK Dev Team

@gatk_dev

Still a 1-in-3 chance of winning one of the 100 prizes we're giving to survey respondents! Tell your friends and la… https://t.co/afHJFgMuV5
17 Nov 17
@ctsa11 @strnr Fair enough; now that we have 280 characters to play with we can say != "GVCF as we define it" (with… https://t.co/eD686VenjI
17 Nov 17
#GATK HaplotypeCaller paper on biorxiv https://t.co/fISg0KM12f #BetterLateThanNever
17 Nov 17
Thanks again for inviting us to @marshallu, we had a great time and enjoyed the very active group of participants! https://t.co/8ymsXvXDhQ
13 Nov 17
@geoffjentry It's so nice to be able to use proper grammar and spelling... #GrammarPolice
9 Nov 17

- Our favorite tweets from others

Wanna be a baller, HaplotypeCaller 20K genotypes in the VCF file Caller, gettin' phased tonight https://t.co/bOGSI4UL23
17 Nov 17
This amazing genomics toolkit helps researchers find insights that save lives - I know! GATK users - please provide… https://t.co/gdY4FDPX8K
2 Nov 17
using GATK to identify SNPs while handing out candy... Happy Halloween! @broadinstitute @gatk_dev #bioinformatics #researchisfun #Halloween
31 Oct 17
Although it made me cry sometimes, I owe them a lot and love them much more. https://t.co/vUj0cBllgn
16 Oct 17
Round of applause at #BOSC2017 for GATK4 being open sourced. https://t.co/WRhTeKtKTX
23 Jul 17
See more of our favorite tweets...